BORN & RAISED, SHELTER ISLAND NY
Shelter Island Custom Home Construction You Can Trust
Born and raised on the Island. We deliver quality construction that feels like home.
At Bartilucci Construction, we build custom homes and renovations for Shelter Island’s coastal conditions. Our team pairs craftsmanship with clear communication handling foundations, framing, roofing, siding, and finishes so your home looks beautiful and lasts. With deep local roots and hands-on experience, we manage the process end-to-end for a smooth, reliable build.
Short forum
Follow us on Instagram
Our Promise
At Bartilucci Construction, we stand by solid quality, clear communication, and dependable results. Your budget and schedule are protected, and every step is explained. From the first foundation pour to the last roofing nail, the work is organized, inspected, and built to hold up on Shelter Island.
.png)
Our Process
-
Listen & Plan – Site visit, clear scope, realistic budget, and timeline.
-
Design & Permits – Coordinate drawings, handle Town approvals, and select locks to protect budget/schedule.
-
Build & Communicate – Clean sites, skilled crews, weekly updates, inspector-ready details, written change orders.
-
Walkthrough & Warranty – Final walkthrough, punch list, close-out package (manuals, finishes, warranties), and post-move-in support.
What We Do
From ground-up custom homes to smart, seamless renovations, we build for the Shelter Island weather and for everyday living.
.webp)
.webp)
Why Choose Bartilucci Construction
Local Roots
We’re not just working on Shelter Island we grew up here. That means we know the soil, the weather, and the local codes inside and out. Every project is planned with these factors in mind, so your home is built to last in our unique coastal environment.
Craftsmanship That Lasts
From framing to finish work, we focus on clean lines, strong structures, and details that age gracefully. Our hands-on construction experience ensures your custom home or renovation looks great today and holds up for decades.
Clear Communication
No surprises, no guesswork. We keep you updated at every stage what’s happening next, what it costs, and why. You’ll always know where your project stands.
On Time and On Budget
We build realistic schedules and protect them. By managing materials, crews, and inspections efficiently, we deliver results when promised without hidden costs.
Pride in Our Name
Bartilucci Construction is more than a business it’s our family name and our reputation. We live here too, and every project we complete reflects our commitment to quality and trust in the community.
Testimonials
Featured Projects
-
Waterfront Family Home Shelter Island
Ground-up custom home with continuous ice-and-water protection, hurricane ties, rain-screen siding, and impact-rated window walls. Efficient systems deliver quiet comfort and views.
Result: A durable, energy-smart home built for Shelter Island weather.
-
Historic Renovation The Heights
Full renovation that preserves character while upgrading performance new envelope, expanded living, modern kitchen, restored trim.
Result: Classic look, modern comfort done to code and built to last.
-
Entertainer’s Deck & Exterior Refresh West Neck
Multi-level composite deck with cable rail, new roofing and siding tied cleanly into the existing structure, plus outdoor shower.
Result: Seamless exterior upgrade that stands up to salt air and heavy use.
